Hiring the right people and building an effective team isn’t as easy as it sounds. Even the most experienced managers and executives face roadblocks that can derail their success. From spotting top talent to building strong networks, the challenges are real—but the solutions are within reach.

Let’s dive into 5 common hiring and leadership challenges and explore how savvy leaders are tackling them head-on.

1. The Danger of a Bad Hire

A bad hire doesn’t just impact your bottom line—it can disrupt your team’s energy, stall productivity, and create unnecessary drama. In fact, a 2017 survey by CareerBuilder found that 74% of employers have hired the wrong person, which led to an average cost of $14,900 per bad hire. Successful leaders know how to spot red flags early. Whether it’s inconsistencies in a candidate's story or subtle hints during an interview, they’ve mastered the art of reading between the lines to ensure they’re bringing the right people on board.

2. Struggling to Spot Hidden Talent

Some candidates are great at selling themselves in an interview, but when it’s time to deliver, they fall flat. On the other hand, truly remarkable talent often gets overlooked. Top managers have sharpened their ability to distinguish between surface-level charm and deep potential, ensuring they recruit people who truly elevate their teams.

Case Study: How Google Changed the Game in Hiring Google, known for its innovation, once relied on traditional hiring methods like résumés and academic credentials. However, the company found that its top performers often didn’t fit the conventional mold. To address this, Google revamped its process to focus on potential over pedigree.

By using structured behavioral interviews and problem-solving tasks, Google identified traits like critical thinking, adaptability, and cultural fit. One standout hire was Laszlo Bock, later SVP of People Operations, whose unconventional background helped transform Google's approach to talent and culture.

The Result: This shift allowed Google to uncover hidden gems, fueling innovation and growth.
Takeaway: True potential often lies beyond the résumé. Creative assessments can help managers find exceptional talent others overlook.

3. Leadership Isolation Is Real

Being a leader can feel lonely. Without the right community, it’s easy to get stuck in your own head or feel like no one understands the weight of your role. Research from Harvard Business Review highlights that 58% of managers report feeling isolated at work. Great leaders don’t try to go it alone—they leverage the power of professional networks, tapping into shared wisdom, new ideas, and mentorship that help them thrive.

Joining a professional network doesn’t just offer advice; it gives leaders the support system they need to navigate challenges, innovate, and grow. Whether it’s sharing strategies, learning from others’ mistakes, or finding a sounding board, having a community is a game-changer.

4. Building Teams That Deliver Results

Creating a high-performing team is about more than just hiring the right people—it’s about fostering an environment where collaboration thrives and everyone contributes to a shared vision.

What Smart Managers Do:

Align team goals with company objectives to ensure clarity and purpose.
Encourage open communication to build trust and collaboration.
Regularly assess team dynamics and address roadblocks before they become bigger issues.

One strategy many leaders use is assembling teams with complementary skill sets and personalities. This not only enhances productivity but also ensures diverse perspectives lead to innovative solutions.

5. Wasting Time and Energy in Recruitment

Let’s face it: hiring is time-consuming. Between reviewing résumés, conducting interviews, and onboarding, the process can drag on for weeks—sometimes months. The longer it takes, the more resources you burn, and the higher the chances of missing out on great candidates. A LinkedIn report found that 60% of recruiters say time-to-hire is a significant challenge.

How Smart Managers Solve This:

Streamline the hiring process with clear job descriptions and efficient interview schedules.
Use technology, like applicant tracking systems (ATS), to narrow down candidates faster.
Implement practical assessments to evaluate skills and fit early in the process.

By prioritizing efficiency without compromising on quality, managers can reduce hiring bottlenecks, make faster decisions, and keep their teams running smoothly.

Take the Next Step in Your Hiring Journey

Becoming an exceptional hiring manager isn’t just about filling positions—it’s about bringing the right people into your team to drive success. By refining your hiring process and learning to spot top talent, you can make smarter decisions that lead to stronger, more effective teams.

Ready to elevate your recruitment skills and leadership?

Our guide on How to become a recruitment manager offers the insights and strategies you need to build a high-performing team with confidence.

Besides, these are useful tips if you want to cultivate your skills as a leader:

Leadership Development Guide: Watch Strategy (Yes, it's Free)
Process Improvement Toolkit: Download PDF (Yes, it's Free)
Workforce Flywheel Framework Training: Watch here (Yes, it's Free)
Tools for HR Leaders Access Here (Yes, it's Free)
Hiring and Interview Skills to Recruit Top Talent as Manager Here (Yes, this is exclusive)

References:

SHRM. (2021). "The Impact of Bad Hires on Organizational Culture and Performance." Society for Human Resource Management.
Google. (2020). "How Google Builds High-Performing Teams." Google Careers Blog.
McKinsey & Company. (2021). "The Role of Leadership in Driving Team Performance." McKinsey Insights. Link
Bock, L. (2015). "Work Rules! Insights from Inside Google That Will Transform How You Live and Lead." Twelve Books.

Author information:
My Hoa Passionate Learning & Program Officer
VSHR Pro Academy

5 Painful Hiring and Leadership Challenges (And How Smart Managers Solve Them)